Review: Google Pixel 11 Pro HiLight is a dud, but the cameras make up for it
Google didn’t really bring the heat with most of the Pixel 11 lineup this year. The base Pixel model and the foldable Pixel 11 Pro Fold are both totally fine, but they don’t stand out among the competition thanks to minor and unremarkable changes.
That’s mostly true for the flagship Pixel 11 Pro as well, but what it lacks in incredible innovations, it makes up for in being a very good, very easy-to-use Android device with excellent cameras. Photography is fun on the Pixel 11 Pro, which is not something I feel about many handsets these days. A combination of hardware and software makes your images consistently look nice, even in challenging lighting conditions.
Between that and acceptable levels of performance and battery life, the new Pro is the smartphone I recommend getting in the Pixel 11 lineup. Just don’t buy it for HiLight.
Google Pixel 11 Pro review: The inevitable price increase
Credit: René Ramos / Mashable
Despite filling the lede for review with a bunch of praise for the phone, I’m going to pivot right away into something I dislike about it: the starting price. At $1,099, it’s $100 more than the Pixel 10 Pro was at launch. There are some caveats to that, as I’ll cover momentarily, but the fact of the matter is that you can’t get a Pixel 11 Pro for (technically) less than $1,000 anymore. That stinks.
But at least the colors this year are nice: Canyon, Olive, Fog, and Obsidian. I reviewed the Canyon model and I found it pretty easy on the eyes. Here are the basic specs for the Pixel 11 Pro:
-
Display: 6.3 inches with 1280×2586 resolution, 1-120Hz refresh rate, and 3,600 nits peak brightness
-
Processor: Google Tensor G6
-
RAM: 12/16GB
-
Storage: 256/512GB/1TB
-
Battery: 4,850mAh
-
Rear cameras: 50MP main, 48MP ultra-wide, 48MP telephoto
-
Front camera: 42MP
Alright, so, there are a few things to clarify here. The display’s size and resolution haven’t changed at all since the Pixel 10 Pro, but the peak brightness has, with an extra 300 nits on this year’s device to boost daytime performance. In outdoor usage, I had no problem clearly seeing what was on the screen, so I’d say that little boost did its job. The base Pixel 11 didn’t get the same upgrade, so that’s one of the things you get for the extra money.
Credit: René Ramos / Mashable
One major drawback, though, is that Google has cut the RAM on the lowest-end model to 12GB. Last year, you could get a Pixel 10 Pro with 256GB of storage and 16GB of RAM. This year, the 256GB model is tied to 12GB of RAM, while the 512GB and 1TB models get those four extra gigs of memory. I totally get that we live in the world of RAMageddon, but it still blows to see a phone downgrade year-over-year like that. I guess I should get used to it.
HiLight doesn’t impress me much
HiLight is a little light module built into the camera bar on Pixel 11 Pro devices. This is supposed to be the one major hardware innovation this year, but I just don’t see it. It only lights up when Gemini is in use or when someone calls you on the phone, two use cases that almost never happen in my life (aside from spam calls). It’s theoretically a decent way to notify the user that something is up when the phone is turned over, but as it is right now, HiLight is a dud.
Lastly, I’ll mention that the camera bar on the Pixel 11 Pro is much bulkier than on the base model. That’s not a huge deal, especially if you put a case on the phone, but it is noticeable if you happen to have used both phones.
Credit: René Ramos / Mashable
Google Pixel 11 Pro: Performance
I would describe the Pixel 11 Pro as “performant.” Everything loads quickly and smoothly, and on-device AI tasks process in just a few seconds. It’s not outstanding among other flagship smartphones, but these days, it’s almost impossible for everyday performance to do that. Every phone is fast now. It’s great.
Weirdly, the Geekbench 7 benchmarking software didn’t agree with my IRL assessment. The Pixel 11 Pro got stunningly low scores on the test I ran: 1,448 for single-core CPU testing and 4,642 for multi-core testing. That’s multiple thousands of points worse than the base Pixel 11, but I swear there is not a meaningful difference in practical use. Google’s Tensor chips have always underperformed in Geekbench tests, so I’m guessing there’s just something odd happening here that isn’t really reflective of reality.
Google Pixel 11 Pro: AI features
One nice thing Google does is provide AI feature parity across its entire device lineup each year, and the Pixel 11 series is no different. As with the base Pixel 11 and the Pro Fold, the Pixel 11 Pro will use contextual on-screen prompts, such as a text message someone sent about a restaurant reservation, to surface relevant information or create calendar entries for you. These aren’t exactly life-changing features, but they might save you a little bit of time.
The real AI juice this year is in Magic Capture and Rambler. Magic Capture is a new capture mode built into the Camera app that works the same as recording video, but once you’re done recording, the phone will slice up the video into several clear, pristine still images for you, complete with automatic cropping and unblurring. I have found this great for getting good photos of pigeons around New York City, as they’re fidgety and quick to scatter if you move too suddenly or get too close.
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
I’m as big an AI skeptic as there is, but Magic Capture works for me because it’s genuinely useful and isn’t really trying to replace any of your cognitive functions. It’s not creating new information; it’s just giving you usable still images from videos.
Rambler, meanwhile, is a new function built into Gboard that’s able to clean up your speech-to-text recordings. If you’re prone to “umms” and changing direction mid-sentence, Rambler does a nice job of turning whatever nonsense you give it into a readable sentence. I imagine this will be a godsend for people who like to dictate their text messages.
Google Pixel 11 Pro: Battery life
Credit: René Ramos / Mashable
Google rates each Pixel 11 device for 30 hours of battery life, and in my testing, that’s about what I got out of them. The Pixel 11 Pro is no different.
Our testing method involves playing an HD video in full-screen on the device until it dies. Using that rubric, I got about 29.5 hours of juice out of the Pixel 11 Pro. As always, there are plenty of ways to squeeze even more life out of a phone, such as turning off 120Hz support and using battery-saving modes. I am confident you can go more than a full day without charging this phone.
Google Pixel 11 Pro review: The camera test
The real reason to get a Pixel 11 Pro (and this is true most years of the Pixel Pro phones) is the camera array. The rear cameras may not wow you with giant megapixel counts, but between the hardware and Google’s patented software magic, it’s so easy for even someone like me who knows nothing about photography to get great photos on a Pixel 11 Pro.
Every photo I took came out looking roughly like this, with clarity, vividness, and great color accuracy.
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
Night Sight is excellent, too. These plants are nigh-invisible at night, but with Night Sight, it looks like I photographed them during the day.
No Night Sight.
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
Night Sight.
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
I’m always a fan of macro photography, and the Pixel 11 Pro takes pristine shots of things like plants up close and personal.
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
I’d also like to shout out the digital zoom, which Google upped to 120x this year after it topped out at 100x on Pixel 10 Pro. This has been my favorite parlor trick on Pixel phones for a few years now. It’s really amazing how good photos taken from super far away can look on this device. In the image on the left, you can’t even see the church steeple that’s the subject of the image on the right, but I was standing in the same place, looking in the same direction for both shots.
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
Credit: Alex Perry / Mashable
Between all of that and the addition of Magic Capture, this is a great phone for photography.
Google Pixel 11 Pro: The verdict
In case it wasn’t clear, if you absolutely must have a phone from the Pixel 11 series and the extra money is not a hurdle for you, I’d recommend the Pixel 11 Pro. It’s just a rock-solid Android phone with a really great photography suite. Sure, HiLight is a bust, and the camera bar is a little bulky relative to the base Pixel 11, but those are compromises that are worth living with if you want the best Pixel 11 phone.
